You know how it goes.
You’re in the kitchen, ready to make something wonderful, when you reach into the spice cabinet and discover you’re missing one little ingredient.
Pumpkin pie spice.
Of course.
Because apparently the spice cabinet didn’t get the memo about what we’re baking today. 😂
That’s actually how I got into making my own pumpkin pie spice. I needed it for my pumpkin whoopie pies, and rather than make another trip to the grocery store, I decided to mix up my own.
And you know what? I liked it better.
It’s incredibly simple, takes only a few minutes, and uses five spices you may already have sitting in your cabinet.
Why Make Your Own Pumpkin Pie Spice?
First, let’s clear something up.
Despite the name, pumpkin pie spice doesn’t actually contain pumpkin.
It’s a blend of warm spices traditionally used to flavor pumpkin pies, cakes, cookies, and all those wonderful fall treats.
And there’s something particularly nice about making your own.
You control the blend, you know exactly what’s in it, and you don’t have to buy another little jar that inevitably disappears into the back of the spice cabinet.
Plus, if you’re anything like me, you’ll find plenty of reasons to use it beyond pumpkin pie.
The Five Spices That Make It Special
My homemade pumpkin pie spice uses five simple ingredients.
Cinnamon: The foundation of the blend. Warm, sweet, and responsible for much of that familiar fall aroma.
Ground ginger: Adds a little brightness and gentle warmth that keeps the mixture from tasting flat.
Nutmeg: Brings an earthy, slightly sweet richness that pairs beautifully with pumpkin.
Allspice: Despite its name, it’s a single spice, not a mixture of several. It has wonderful warm notes that remind me of cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg.
Ground cloves: Strong, aromatic, and a little goes a long way. Cloves give the blend that unmistakable holiday-spice flavor.
Together, they make a beautifully balanced mixture that’s wonderful for baking.
Homemade Pumpkin Pie Spice Recipe
The best part? There’s no baking, cooking, or fancy equipment involved.
Just measure, mix, and store.

Ingredients
Method
- Mix all and store in an airtight container.
My Favorite Way to Use It: Pumpkin Whoopie Pies
Now, here’s where things get delicious.
One of my favorite reasons to keep this spice blend on hand is my homemade pumpkin whoopie pies.
Soft, pumpkin-spiced little cakes with a creamy cream cheese filling sandwiched between them.
They’re everything I love about fall baking, and they’re even better with a homemade spice blend.
If you haven’t made them yet, you’re missing out.
Try my Pumpkin Whoopie Pies and put that freshly mixed pumpkin pie spice to good use.
And yes, you’re absolutely allowed to sample a little of the cream cheese filling while assembling them.
I certainly won’t tell. 😂
Other Ways to Use Homemade Pumpkin Pie Spice
Don’t let the name limit you to pumpkin desserts.
This little mixture can do quite a bit of work in the kitchen.
Coffee: Add a pinch to your coffee grounds before brewing, or sprinkle a little into a latte.
Oatmeal: Stir a small amount into your morning oatmeal with brown sugar or maple syrup.
French toast: Add it to your egg mixture for a cozy fall breakfast.
Cookies and muffins: Use it in pumpkin, apple, or other warmly spiced baked goods.
Whipped cream: Add just a pinch for a wonderful topping on fall desserts.
Roasted sweet potatoes: Try a light sprinkle with butter and a touch of brown sugar.
And, of course, there’s always pumpkin pie.
How Much Pumpkin Pie Spice Should You Use?
If a recipe calls for pumpkin pie spice, use the amount specified in that recipe.
For a recipe that lists individual spices instead, you can sometimes substitute a prepared blend, but the flavor may be slightly different because each blend has its own proportions.
And if you’re experimenting with coffee, oatmeal, or whipped cream, start small.
You can always add more.
Cloves and nutmeg in particular can become overpowering when you get a little too enthusiastic with the measuring spoon.
How to Store Homemade Pumpkin Pie Spice
Keep your spice blend in a clean, dry container with a tightly fitting lid.
Store it in a cool, dark cabinet rather than beside the stove, where heat and moisture can affect the flavor.
For the best flavor, use fresh ground spices when making your blend.
Ground spices gradually lose their aroma and potency over time, so I like to make a manageable amount and replenish it when needed.
A quick sniff usually tells you quite a bit. If your spices barely smell like anything, they probably won’t add much flavor to your baking, either.
A Little Kitchen Shortcut Worth Keeping
I love recipes like this because they’re simple, useful, and save me from making an unnecessary trip to the store.
Five spices. One bowl. A couple of minutes.
And suddenly that pumpkin dessert you were planning is back on track.
Now, if only the spice cabinet could remember to restock itself.
Until then, I’ll keep making my own.
Good food. Simple ingredients. And one less trip to the grocery store.
